ISM sues Sony for $1.25M over ‘Party’ royalties, claims half-rate payment

Ten years after producing one of Chris Brown’s biggest hits, beat-maker ISM is taking Sony Music to federal court. The numbers tell a story that’s becoming way too familiar in hip-hop: a label’s accounting that doesn’t add up, a creator getting shortchanged, and the kind of contractual games that keep producers fighting for what they’re owed.
ISM (Ishmael Sadiq Montague) filed the suit on October 16 in New York federal court, seeking at least $1,247,500 for the harm claimed, plus punitive damages. The beef centers on “Party,” the 2016 track that featured Usher and Gucci Mane on Chris Brown’s “Heartbreak On a Full Moon” album—a track that became a cultural staple and charted hard. ISM co-produced the joint with A1 (Floyd “A1” Bentley).
Here’s where it gets messy. His deal with Chris Brown Entertainment gave ISM a 1.5% royalty after a split with fellow producer A1. Sony paid his share but used a rate of 0.75%, the filing claims. That means Sony was cutting his check at half the rate he was contractually owed. A July review said he got about half the pay he was due for the last period.
But the lawsuit isn’t just about past royalties—it’s about Sony actively blocking ISM’s ability to sell his future earnings. ISM said he sold royalty interests to Xposure Music Holdings in June. The deal called for Sony to send checks to the buyer from September 1 onward. His suit claims Sony stalled the payee change for six weeks. During those six weeks, ISM says he was forced to sign a new form with terms that would have stripped his audit rights—a classic move to lock down liability.
The strategy allegedly worked. ISM claimed those weeks of talks put pressure on him to take Sony’s terms. He signed the new form on August 29 but said he did not give up his claims. Still, the damage was done. On July 24, staff said there was no account for his share, according to the suit. Four days later, Sony confirmed it was accounting for the Chris Brown track. He cited years of Sony statements as proof that the account was there all along.
This lawsuit lands amid a broader reckoning in the music industry. Earlier this year, Jermaine Dupri sued Sony over an alleged $18 million royalty discrepancy involving So So Def artists—a case that exposed how major labels have historically used separate accounting systems to conceal earnings from producers and label heads. The ISM case follows the same playbook: underpayment, strategic delays, and paperwork designed to bar artists from verifying what they’re actually owed.
For ISM, who’s built a career as a multi-platinum producer and songwriter, this fight is personal. “Party” might be a decade old, but it’s still generating revenue every time it streams, plays on radio, or gets licensed. The royalties keep flowing—just apparently not at the rate ISM agreed to. Sony’s in-house lawyer denied liability on October 15 and called the matter “fully resolved”. ISM clearly disagrees. ISM also asked the court to order an audit and award any unpaid funds it finds.
The 16BARS take: When a major label can cut a producer’s rate in half and then weaponize delayed paperwork to prevent a royalty sale, that’s not accounting—it’s theft with receipts. ISM’s lawsuit is the canary in the coal mine: if Sony can get away with this on a platinum single, what’s happening to every other catalog in their vault?




