Charlie Ehrlich reacts to OJ using his name in ‘If I Did It’

Charlie Ehrlich, OJ Simpson’s accomplice in his 2007 Las Vegas sports memorabilia armed robbery, is now sharing how OJ informed him his first name would be used in “If I Did It.” And the story is exactly as awkward as you’d expect from a conversation between a convicted felon and the dude who co-authored a hypothetical confession to murdering two people.
In a preview clip for Peacock’s upcoming documentary “OJ’s Accomplice,” Charlie claims OJ told him he had to concoct a name for an accomplice in the book so that it could be fictitious, so he used the name Charlie. Real smooth move, right? The guy literally recruited you for an armed robbery in Vegas, got convicted alongside you, and then decides to put your actual first name in a whole book about murdering his ex-wife. Charlie asked OJ “Well, not really, but I do. I mean, couldn’t you say Lou or Fred or Tony?” OJ responded “Ah, don’t worry about it.” Charlie said “F*** it.” That’s not consent—that’s resignation.
To be clear about what went down: On September 13, 2007, a group of men led by Simpson entered a room at the Palace Station hotel in Las Vegas. In Simpson’s hypothetical scenario in “If I Did It,” he created an unwilling accomplice named “Charlie” who urges Simpson not to follow through with his plans to “scare the shit out of” Nicole. The book was supposed to be fiction. It was supposed to be hypothetical. But the name wasn’t. The name was real.
This detail matters because it blurs a line that was already dangerously thin. In his controversial 2007 book, If I Did It, Simpson wrote a hypothetical version of the murders, drawing criticism from both families. Simpson played games with reader perception from day one—the whole conceit was “here’s how I would have done it IF I did it,” which is the kind of linguistic gymnastics that only works when you’re not naming actual accomplices from your actual Vegas felonies in the same document. The book became a cultural artifact of surreal audacity: a man walking free from a murder trial (after a civil judgment against him) publishing a detailed, play-by-play “fictional” scenario where he kills his ex-wife, only to get immediately arrested weeks later for an armed robbery.
What’s wild is that Ehrlich was sentenced to probation after pleading guilty to reduced charges of attempted robbery and attempted accessory to robbery in exchange for testifying against OJ. He cooperated. He took the deal. He testified. And OJ still rolled the dice, used his name anyway, and apparently acted surprised when Charlie objected. The casualness of it—”don’t worry about it”—says everything about how Simpson operated. He genuinely didn’t care if it bothered his accomplice that his real name was now in a hypothetical murder confession. He was going to do what he wanted.
Fast forward to 2026: Ehrlich is on a Peacock documentary telling the world about this conversation, which means the story has legs again. It’s a reminder that Simpson never really respected the line between truth and fiction—or between his world and other people’s lives. Charlie Ehrlich is trying to move on. OJ used his name anyway. That’s the whole conversation.
The 16BARS take: OJ asking his robbery accomplice permission to use his real name in a fake murder confession—and barely listening to the answer—is peak narcissist energy. The guy was convicted of kidnapping and armed robbery literally weeks after publishing “If I Did It,” and he STILL didn’t see the problem.




